A New Law for Indiana and Arkansas

-

 

            There has been much ink spilled over the new “Religious Freedom” act passed now in both Indiana and Arkansas. It is clear from listening to the arguments that it is time for some remedial logic training here in these United States. I am going to point out just two of the major logical fallacies that are being spread there are others. Then we will attempt to exegete the reasons for all of the confusion regarding this law.

            The first fallacy is that of the “straw man”. Opponents of the law bring up the specter of segregated lunch counters and other images from our racist past. They say that restaurants and other places will be able to refuse service based on sexual orientation. This ignores the fact that in this economy no restaurant owner or manager I know would be willing to turn away someone on this basis. They may not like their lifestyle, but their dollars would be welcome. The straw man of segregation and discrimination simply are fear based attempts to sway public opinion but have no basis in fact. This can readily be seen in the states where similar laws are already on the books.

            The second fallacy that is brought up is attacking the man. (Ad Hominem) It seems that some of the people standing around the governor when he signed the legislation have less than stellar records when it comes to gay rights. Then condemn the entire legislation on the basis of their presence alone. Clearly they did not write the law and will not be responsible for its implementation therefore attacks on the law via their persons are invalid.  

            The reasons for the confusion regarding this law are numerous. But they all boil down to fear and fearmongering. Opponents of the law have thus far managed to make people afraid of the law without actually having read the bill. (I have.) Thus they are able to sway people in directions which they would not ordinarily go. As I said earlier there are more logical fallacies operating here than the two I have pointed out. All of them are designed to make people afraid of this law.

            Religious freedom should not make anyone afraid except those who wish to deny this liberty to others. As the descendant of folks who came to these shores in the 1600’s I stand for the religious liberty for which my family sacrificed so much. In coming to these shores my family said no to tyranny. I now say no to the tyranny of fear being foisted on us by irresponsible fearmongering demagogues.

            It is my hope that these laws are kept in place and more like them are put on the books. And let the people judge whether there is an increase in discrimination against any group or individual because of their being in place. After all we have to pass the law in order to know what is in it, (Or we could just read it, it only costs us about 10 minutes of our lives.)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Welcoming the Unwelcome

-
  Scripture: Luke 7:36-38 (NIV) 36  When one of the Pharisees invited Jesus to have dinner with him, he went to the Pharisee’s house and reclined at the table. 37  A woman in that town who lived a sinful life learned that Jesus was eating at the Pharisee’s house, so she came there with an alabaster jar of perfume. 38  As she stood behind him at his feet weeping, she began to wet his feet with her tears. Then she wiped them with her hair, kissed them, and poured perfume on them. Devotion:             First of all, some warnings to my readers. This post will exceed the 500 words I try to limit my posts. Second, this post will contain content people may find offensive or otherwise unfit for print. Please understand that my purpose is neither to offend nor upset but to provoke thought and, hopefully, respectful dialog.             We will use Luke chapter seven as an aid to interpreting the events that occurred last Thursday at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York City. On that da
Read more

Father Forgive Them

-
  Scripture: Luke 23:33-34 (ESV) 33  And when they came to the place that is called The Skull, there they crucified him, and the criminals, one on his right and one on his left. 34  And Jesus said, “Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do.” Devotion:             The situation Jesus finds himself in here in today’s scripture is difficult for us to even imagine. A sham trial, no credible accusations of any kind, let alone any deserving of death, and yet here he is. A brilliant Rabbi, a teacher of the people who never led even one person astray from God’s will. This Holy One of God soon to be food for vultures.             This man who had done nothing wrong had no one in all the crowds who would speak up in his defense lest they be next to face the cross. An innocent man hung between two scoundrels. No voice from heaven declaring that this was the man that they were killing was actually the true Son of God. (See Matthew 3:17, Matthew 17:5, John 12:28) No the heaven
Read more

Transgenderism letter

-
  This is a copy of my letter to my senators, representative, and President Biden. January 15, 2024 Dear President Biden, Senators T. Duckworth, R. Durbin, and Representative D. LaHood             I am writing to you because I am concerned about the situation affecting our children and grandchildren, namely transitioning them from one gender to another. This nation must adjust course concerning these “interventions” because they are dangerous, irreversible, and life-changing. Our country should not be permitting these procedures on minor children under any circumstances. We must also make sure that adults who seek this care are given informed consent as to the risks versus benefits of sex reassignment treatments.             There are many drawbacks to gender-affirming care for minors. Besides the loss of any ability to give or receive sexual pleasure and sterility these treatments cause, there are social and psychological effects that we have no way of identifying because these
Read more